|
MORGAN STANLEY RESEARCH
High Tech Computer Is It Really That Bad? Think Again
Pullback offers buying opportunity:
In our note dated May 7, Diamond Is Good; but Need More Evidence to Get Excited, we noted that we expected some profit-taking pullback in HTC owing to pricing elasticity and a likely change in the competitive landscape post Apple’s announcement of its 3G iPhone. We believe, however, that the Street has overly magnified the impact of Apple’s aggressive pricing strategy, and that this could be another good entry point to accumulate HTC stock. On an acceleration in 3Q top-line momentum driven by restocking strength, an unbroken converged device story, reduced market expectations, and attractive valuations (14x 2008e US GAAP yet better earnings visibility, high ROE, and brand value), we reiterate our Overweight-V rating.
Don’t compare Apple with Orange:
Vodafone Italy disclosed its prepaid pricing plan for Apple’s 3G iPhone at €499/€569 (US$773/US$881) for 8/16G models instead of US$199 (vs. HTC’s Diamond’s US$169) for postpaid only. We estimate the wholesale price of the 3G iPhone to operators at slightly above HTC’s Diamond with a marginally higher subsidy needed. For channel markets where Apple does not have exposure, HTC will launch a lower-priced EDGE version to grab share. We hold our view that HTC’s OM will be on a downtrend in 2H08 owing to lighter GM (rising ODM mix) and increasing opex for marketing the Diamond family, but the rate of contraction may not be as bad as feared.
The converged device market is yet crowded: Despite Apple’s wider coverage, it still offers exclusive deals to one operator in each of several major countries such as the US, Germany, the UK, France, and Spain (accounting for around 60% of W. Europe) and so far has signed up only multiple operators in India and Italy.
Other operators in the same region that do not have the iPhone 3G option might need to adopt another device to retain subscribers. We reckon HTC’s customized service, WM OS-focus, and innovative product offerings are key to its staying competitive among other brands.
Compal Communications 08 Shipment Target Cut Echoes Our Concerns on Prolonged Weakness into 2H
Remain Cautious:
We were not surprised to see CCI lower its 08 shipment target to an estimated 48m units as signs of recovery are still lacking at Moto (dip 15-20% QoQ in 2Q; a mild seasonal pickup in 3Q). While CCI has dedicated efforts to obtain new clients (Nokia and LG) and diversify its product portfolio to smartphone or wireless data card, we have not seen any substantial contributions yet from these efforts. Moreover, we believe heavy competition from EMS and China handset brands in low-end segment will put pressure on CCI for order sustainability and margin outlook. Thus, we reiterate our Underweight, given its high business uncertainty, declining ROE trend, and rich valuation of 13.4x 08E PE vs. 11.9x for FIH (HK9.65).
No recovery at Moto; new Nokia models not big savior: At AGM on June 13, CCI lowered its 08E official shipment target to 48m units from previous 60m units, with the shortfall mainly from lukewarm momentum at Moto. Even though new CDMA project wins from Nokia will launch in 3Q with monthly run rate at 500-800k units or total shipments mounting to 3-4m units, the incremental contribution for CCI is not yet able to make up Moto’s shortfall. We now look for shipments to reach 12m in 3Q and14.5m in 4Q, or total 46.7m units in 08E, lower than our previous estimate of 48.6m units.
Implications:
We cut our 2008/09E EPS by 11%/8% to reflect further reduced shipment assumption on Moto’s weakness. We thus lower our PT to NT$41 (12x 08 P/E on US GAAP). We believe the gloomy outlook will continue to cap CCI's price performance even though 8.7% cash yield likely acts as a buffer near term. |